Citizens Interstate
Prepayment Execution

Defeasance vs. Yield Maintenance: Costs, Timelines, and Closing Execution

When refinancing or selling a commercial property encumbered by fixed-rate institutional debt (such as CMBS, life insurance, or agency mortgages), borrowers cannot simply pay off the outstanding principal balance. Lenders mandate either Yield Maintenance or Defeasance to guarantee their contractual yield. Understanding the execution mechanics and financial costs of each is critical for transaction timing.

Key Financing Parameters & Standards

Defeasance DefinitionSubstituting real estate collateral with a customized portfolio of US Treasury securities
Yield Maintenance DefinitionCash penalty paying the present value of remaining interest payments above current Treasuries
Governing Loan TypesCMBS & Structured Debt = Defeasance | Life Insurance & Portfolio Banks = Yield Maintenance
Typical Execution TimelineDefeasance: 30 to 45 days | Yield Maintenance: 5 to 10 days
Third Parties in DefeasanceDefeasance consultant, securities broker, CPA firm, successor borrower, rating agencies
Open Window BenefitMost fixed-rate loans allow par prepayment (0% penalty) during the final 3 to 6 months

* Prepayment penalty formulas, lockout periods (typically 2 years post-securitization for CMBS), and open windows are defined in the original promissory note.

Defeasance: Collateral Substitution Mechanics

Defeasance is not a loan payoff; it is a legally binding collateral substitution. CMBS loans are packaged into public bond trusts where bondholders expect uninterrupted monthly interest distributions. Prepaying principal early would disrupt bond cash flows.

Under defeasance, the borrower uses sale or refinance proceeds to purchase a customized portfolio of U.S. Treasury securities and federal agency bonds. The coupon payments and principal maturities of these Treasuries match the exact remaining monthly debt service of the original loan.

The Role of the Successor Borrower

Once the Treasury portfolio is purchased, the original borrower transfers the loan and securities collateral to a specialized "Successor Borrower" entity (managed by a professional defeasance company). The original real estate is completely released from the mortgage lien, allowing the property to be sold or refinanced with a clean title.

Yield Maintenance: Cash Settlement Penalty

Yield Maintenance is a mathematical cash settlement penalty paid directly to the lender at closing. The formula calculates the present value of the remaining contractual interest payments on the note, discounted at current Treasury yields, minus the unpaid principal balance:

Interest Rate Environment Impact

  • Declining Interest Rate Environment: When current Treasury yields fall below the note rate, the yield maintenance penalty spikes significantly because the lender cannot reinvest funds at comparable returns.
  • Rising Interest Rate Environment: When market yields exceed the note rate, the yield maintenance penalty drops to the minimum contractual floor (typically 1.0% of the outstanding balance).
Frequently Answered Questions

Common Questions About Defeasance vs. Yield Maintenance: Costs, Timelines, and Closing Execution

Direct, transparent answers regarding underwriting standards, documentation, and process.

Defeasance Diligence

What is defeasance in commercial real estate lending?

Direct Answer
Defeasance is the process of releasing a commercial property from a mortgage lien by replacing the real estate collateral with a portfolio of U.S. Treasury securities that replicates the loan's remaining principal and interest payments.
It allows CMBS bondholders to receive their expected yield while permitting the property owner to sell or refinance the real estate debt-free.
Penalty Comparison

What is the difference between yield maintenance and defeasance?

Direct Answer
Yield maintenance is a direct cash penalty paid to the lender calculating the present value difference between the note rate and current Treasuries, while defeasance requires purchasing an actual portfolio of government bonds and transferring the debt to a successor borrower.
Yield maintenance is faster to execute (5-10 days), whereas defeasance takes 30-45 days and requires third-party consultants, CPAs, and servicer approvals.
Commercial Real Estate Capital Advisory

Ready to Size Your Commercial Transaction?

Connect with our commercial underwriting team. We provide prompt indicative pricing, leverage sizing, and lender placement strategy upon scenario review.

Citizens Interstate

Citizens Interstate is a commercial mortgage brokerage arranging debt financing for commercial real estate investors and business owners nationwide.

Beverly Hills OfficeCitizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate
9025 Wilshire Blvd, Suite 304, Beverly Hills, CA 90211
Kansas City OfficeCitizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate
4600 Madison Ave, 2nd Floor, Kansas City, MO 64112-1283

Financing

Resources

Corporate & Legal

Commercial Debt & Advisory
Equal Opportunity Financing

Citizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate. Commercial real estate financing arranged for business-purpose transactions nationwide.

Website Under Development

Citizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate is currently preparing for future commercial financing operations and is not accepting loan applications or arranging financing through this website.

Information presented is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to lend, broker, or arrange financing. Services will become available only where and when legally authorized, following any required regulatory approvals.

LEGAL NOTICE & DISCLOSURES: Citizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate is currently preparing for future commercial financing operations and is not accepting loan applications or arranging financing through this website. Information presented is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to lend, broker, or arrange financing. Services will become available only where and when legally authorized, following any required regulatory approvals. All commercial loans originated, arranged, or syndicated by Citizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate are strictly business-purpose commercial loans made to legal entities (e.g., LLCs, Corporations, Partnerships) or eligible commercial borrowers. Rates, leverage terms, fees, and program parameters are indicative only, subject to market fluctuations, property underwriting, and credit review, and do not represent a binding commitment to lend until formal loan documentation is executed.

Citizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate • 9025 Wilshire Blvd, Suite 304, Beverly Hills, CA 90211 | Citizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate • 4600 Madison Ave, 2nd Floor, Kansas City, MO 64112-1283 | Email: dealdesk@citizensinterstate.com | Phone: (310) 717-3478

© 2026 Citizens Interstate, Inc. DBA Citizens Interstate. All rights reserved.
FAQs•Contact•Privacy•Terms